Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Your spouse's NGO applies for a grant
You are a district collector. A state scheme lets your office give grants to NGOs for adult literacy. Your spouse runs a well-regarded NGO that has worked in the district for ten years, and it has applied. Its proposal is one of the strongest on paper. A local newspaper has started asking which NGOs will be chosen.
How do you handle the grant decision?
Three ways to act
- 1Recuse yourself and let a committee decide without you
- 2Ask your spouse to withdraw the application
- 3Decide yourself, since the proposal is strong
1. Recuse yourself and let a committee decide without you
The decision can be seen as fair and the NGO is judged on merit, but critics may still say the committee felt your influence.
Values: Impartiality and public trust
2. Ask your spouse to withdraw the application
There is no question of favour, but a capable NGO and the learners it serves lose out because of your post.
Values: Avoiding any appearance of bias, at a cost to merit
3. Decide yourself, since the proposal is strong
A good proposal may be funded quickly, but the decision looks partial and may be challenged.
Values: Outcome and efficiency over process
Think about it
Should a public servant's family pay a price for that servant's office, and how much?