Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Flood relief: one area today
You are the district collector of a flood-hit district. Relief material, such as food, tarpaulins and medicines, can reach only one area today. Village A has been cut off for three days, and the latest report says it is the worst hit. Village B is less affected. A local MLA calls and insists that relief go to Village B first, because it is in his constituency, and hints that he will complain about you to the state government.
What would you do, and what values does each choice serve?
Three ways to act
- 1Send relief to Village A; record the MLA's request.
- 2Split the relief between both villages.
- 3Send it to Village B first to avoid conflict.
1. Send relief to Village A; record the MLA's request.
The worst-hit village is helped first. The MLA may complain to the state government, but the request is on record.
Values: Impartiality, courage and accountability
2. Split the relief between both villages.
Both villages get some help, but Village A, the worst hit, may get less than it needs.
Values: Compassion and fairness, but weaker on urgent need
3. Send it to Village B first to avoid conflict.
Village B gets help first, and the conflict with the MLA is avoided for now. Village A, the worst hit, waits longer.
Values: Avoiding conflict; sacrifices impartiality and compassion
Think about it
When pressure comes from a powerful person, which value should guide your first decision, and why?