Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Dilemmas

A hospital wing and a pending clearance

Updated 2026-11-14

You are a member of a state body that reviews environmental clearances. A company whose expansion proposal is before you offers, under its CSR budget, to build a new children's wing at the district hospital. A senior official hints that the hospital wing would be a big public gain and the clearance should be 'handled positively'. The proposal has unresolved questions about groundwater use.

How do you handle the clearance?

Three ways to act

You
  1. 1Judge the proposal only on its environmental merits
  2. 2Ask the company to answer the groundwater questions before any decision
  3. 3Clear it with conditions so the hospital wing goes ahead

1. Judge the proposal only on its environmental merits

The process stays independent, but the company may withdraw the CSR offer and the senior may be unhappy.

Values: Objectivity and independence of regulation

2. Ask the company to answer the groundwater questions before any decision

Public gain stays possible if the concerns are met, but the link between CSR and clearance remains unspoken and uneasy.

Values: Due diligence with openness to public benefit

3. Clear it with conditions so the hospital wing goes ahead

The district gets a hospital wing soon, but a clearance is seen as tied to a gift and the groundwater risk is passed on.

Values: Immediate public welfare over regulatory integrity

Think about it

Can a good outcome justify a decision process that others would see as bought?

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →