Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Sharing citizen data with a start-up
You are a municipal commissioner. A start-up offers to build a free app that predicts water pipe bursts and plans repairs. To train it, the firm asks for the city's data on water connections, which includes names, addresses and monthly use for every household. The mayor is keen, and the firm says it will keep the data safe. There is no written agreement yet on how the data will be used or deleted.
Do you share the data?
Three ways to act
- 1Share it now so the project can start
- 2Share only anonymised data under a written agreement
- 3Refuse until the city has a data-sharing policy
1. Share it now so the project can start
The city may get a useful tool quickly, but residents' personal data goes out without clear limits or their knowledge.
Values: Innovation and public service delivery
2. Share only anonymised data under a written agreement
Repairs can still be planned and privacy is better protected, but it takes longer and the firm may say the data is less useful.
Values: Purpose limitation and privacy with innovation
3. Refuse until the city has a data-sharing policy
No personal data is put at risk, but the city may lose a free tool and the mayor may be unhappy.
Values: Caution and data protection over speed
Think about it
Who owns data that citizens give the state to get a service, and who can decide its other uses?