Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Your cousin is on the interview list
You chair an interview board for contract posts in a district health society. On the morning of the interviews you see that your cousin is one of the candidates. You have not met in years, and nobody on the board knows you are related. The interviews start in an hour, and finding a replacement chair at short notice would delay the process for weeks.
What do you do about the interview board?
Three ways to act
- 1Declare the relationship and step aside
- 2Stay on, but declare it and not mark your cousin
- 3Say nothing, since you are not close
1. Declare the relationship and step aside
The process stays clean and you are on record, but the interviews may be postponed and candidates who travelled far may be inconvenienced.
Values: Impartiality and transparency over convenience
2. Stay on, but declare it and not mark your cousin
The interviews go ahead and the board knows of the link, but others may still feel your presence affects the outcome.
Values: Practical fairness with partial disclosure
3. Say nothing, since you are not close
There is no delay, but if the link comes out later the selection may be challenged and your integrity questioned.
Values: Efficiency over the appearance of fairness
Think about it
Is a conflict of interest about what you would actually do, or about what others can reasonably believe?