Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Schoolchildren for a public event
You are a block education officer. A local elected representative is inaugurating a new road and asks that students from nearby government schools line up along the route with flags during school hours. Head teachers have called you, unsure what to do. The representative has helped get funds for school buildings and expects cooperation. Exams are three weeks away.
What do you tell the head teachers?
Three ways to act
- 1Say no: children stay in class during school hours
- 2Allow a small group for a short time with parents' consent
- 3Allow it, since the event is official
1. Say no: children stay in class during school hours
Teaching time and children's dignity are protected, but the representative may be offended and future support for schools may suffer.
Values: Children's interest and neutrality of public institutions
2. Allow a small group for a short time with parents' consent
The request is partly met and disruption is limited, but children are still used for a public show and a precedent is set.
Values: Compromise and goodwill with limits
3. Allow it, since the event is official
Relations with the representative stay good, but children lose study time and schools are drawn into publicity.
Values: Cooperation with authority over children's interest
Think about it
Is it ever right to use children's presence to lend warmth to a public event? What would make it right?