Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Referrals to a private clinic
You are the chief medical officer of a district. Patients complain that a senior surgeon at the district hospital often says the hospital's waiting list is long and suggests they see him at a private clinic in the evening, where he charges fees. He is one of only two surgeons, works long hours and is popular with many patients. If you act strictly, he may resign and surgeries at the hospital would fall sharply.
What do you do about the surgeon?
Three ways to act
- 1Start a formal inquiry under the service rules
- 2Warn him privately and fix the waiting-list system
- 3Let it be, as he serves many patients
1. Start a formal inquiry under the service rules
The rules are upheld and patients are protected from pressure, but the hospital may lose a skilled surgeon.
Values: Accountability and patients' rights
2. Warn him privately and fix the waiting-list system
The practice may stop and he stays, but patients already pushed to pay get no remedy.
Values: Correction and continuity of service
3. Let it be, as he serves many patients
Surgeries continue at today's level, but poor patients keep being nudged to pay for what should be free.
Values: Service output over fairness
Think about it
When a valued professional bends the rules, does their value to the system change what should be done?