Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A rumour of a leaked paper
You are the controller of a state recruitment examination to be held in two days for over two lakh candidates. A message on a messaging app claims the paper has leaked and shows a few questions. Your team cannot yet confirm whether they match the real paper. Postponing would cost money and upset candidates who have travelled; going ahead risks an unfair exam if the leak is real.
What do you do about the exam?
Three ways to act
- 1Postpone and set a fresh paper
- 2Go ahead with a reserve paper set already
- 3Go ahead as planned and investigate after
1. Postpone and set a fresh paper
Fairness is protected whatever the truth, but lakhs of candidates are inconvenienced and the department is criticised for delay.
Values: Fairness and caution over cost
2. Go ahead with a reserve paper set already
The date is kept and the leaked set, if any, is useless, but the reserve paper may not have been checked as carefully.
Values: Continuity with a reasonable safeguard
3. Go ahead as planned and investigate after
Candidates are spared disruption, but if the leak is real the results may be cancelled later, which harms everyone more.
Values: Stability now over certainty of fairness
Think about it
When you cannot know the facts in time, what should guide a decision that affects lakhs of people?