Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Dilemmas

The figures your predecessor left behind

Updated 2026-10-20

You are a newly posted block development officer. Before a state-level review, you find that your predecessor reported a sanitation scheme's coverage as almost complete, but field checks suggest only about two-thirds of households are covered. Your district head, whose own assessment depends on these numbers, advises you to let the old figures stand and close the gap quietly over the year. Correcting the report now will show the block, and the district, in poor light.

What do you do about the inflated figures?

Three ways to act

You
  1. 1Report the true figures at the review
  2. 2Keep the old figures and fix gaps quietly
  3. 3Put the discrepancy in writing to your superior first

1. Report the true figures at the review

The record becomes honest and the gap may get resources, but your relationship with your superior may sour and the district's standing may drop.

Values: Honesty and accountability over loyalty

2. Keep the old figures and fix gaps quietly

There is no immediate conflict and coverage may improve, but false data stays in the system, and you share responsibility if it surfaces.

Values: Harmony and pragmatism over truthfulness

3. Put the discrepancy in writing to your superior first

Your superior gets a chance to correct it through proper channels and you have a record, but the correction may be delayed and friction may follow.

Values: Due process and hierarchy, with a paper trail

Think about it

If official data is wrong, who is harmed by the error, and does staying silent make you part of it?

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →