Ethics case studies · Police
Speed against fairness
A seven-year-old girl has been missing for four days in a town in your district, where you are the Deputy Commissioner of Police. Crowds have blocked the highway, television channels run the story every hour, and a minister has said publicly that an arrest will be made 'within 48 hours'. Your investigating team has picked up a migrant labourer who worked near the girl's home and has no alibi. There is no physical evidence against him, and he speaks little of the local language. Your team wants to announce his arrest to calm the town. A junior officer believes CCTV footage from a petrol pump, which will take three more days to recover, may show someone else. Your seniors are asking for 'results'.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Missing child and family: Finding her, and the real culprit.
- Migrant labourer: Liberty and fair treatment.
- Townspeople: Safety and calm.
- Your team and seniors: Credibility under pressure.
What pulls against what
A quick arrest would calm the public, but a wrong one harms an innocent and leaves the child at risk.
The options
- Announce the arrest: buys calm, but risks injustice and stops the real search.
- Release him and say nothing: fair to him, but public anger grows and trust falls.
- Treat him as a witness with legal aid and an interpreter, speed up the CCTV recovery, and brief the public honestly: slower, criticism likely.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Speed matters for the child, so put resources on every lead; but an arrest needs evidence, not a deadline.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Kant: never treat a person merely as a means, here a man used to calm a crowd.