Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Police

Loyalty against law

Updated 2026-11-03

You are Superintendent of Police in a mid-sized district. Inspector Rawat is one of your most effective officers; three years ago he pulled you out of a burning vehicle during a riot. Last night, a young man held for a phone theft was taken to hospital with injuries. The station diary says he fell, but a constable tells you privately that Inspector Rawat beat him during questioning. The young man's family has filed a complaint, and the hospital report notes injuries consistent with blows. Other officers in the station are watching how you respond; some say the inspector is being targeted by 'bad elements'. The district magistrate has asked for your report by tomorrow, and the state human rights commission may take notice.

Identify the ethical issues involved. What course of action would you take, and why?

You ????
4 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You Injured young manInspector RawatConstable who spokePolice force and public
  • Injured young man: Justice and safety in custody.
  • Inspector Rawat: Career and fair inquiry.
  • Constable who spoke: Protection from retaliation.
  • Police force and public: Trust in lawful policing.

What pulls against what

Personal gratitude and team loyalty pull against the legal duty to act on custodial violence.

The options

  1. Accept the diary entry: keeps morale, but buries abuse and breaks the law.
  2. Transfer the inspector quietly: looks like action, but no inquiry and no justice.
  3. Register the complaint, order an independent inquiry, move the inspector off duty meanwhile, protect the constable: hurts a bond and morale.

One reasoned choice

Option 3. Gratitude is owed to the person, but the uniform's duty is to the law; a fair inquiry also protects the inspector if innocent.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Rule of law: no one, however valued, is above it; D.K. Basu guidelines set the custody rules.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →