Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Case studies

Speed against fairness

Updated 2026-11-03

The High Court has ordered your municipal corporation to clear encroachments on a major storm-water drain within 30 days, before the monsoon. Last year, blocked drains caused flooding in which houses were damaged across the city. About 400 families live in shacks along the drain, some for over 20 years; many have ration cards and voter IDs at that address. The corporation has no ready housing to offer. Your engineers say partial clearing will not fix the flooding. Activists plan to approach the Court for more time, while residents of flooded colonies demand immediate demolition. As Municipal Commissioner, you must submit an action plan to the Court in a week.

What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.

You ????
4 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You Drain-side familiesFlood-hit residentsHigh CourtCorporation
  • Drain-side families: Shelter, livelihood, schooling.
  • Flood-hit residents: Safety from floods.
  • High Court: Compliance with its order.
  • Corporation: Lawful, humane action.

What pulls against what

A court deadline and flood safety demand speed; the families' right to shelter demands a fair process.

The options

  1. Demolish within 30 days without rehousing: complies fast, but makes 400 families homeless.
  2. Seek a long delay: protects families now, but flood risk stays and the Court may be displeased.
  3. Propose a phased plan: clear the most critical stretches first, give transit housing and rent support, survey for PMAY-Urban, and ask the Court for limited time: costs money, partial risk remains.

One reasoned choice

Option 3. Courts generally accept plans that combine compliance with humane resettlement; do not treat speed and dignity as enemies.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Olga Tellis (1985): the Supreme Court linked livelihood to the right to life under Article 21.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →