Ethics case studies · Case studies
Transparency against privacy
You head a state's welfare data department. Last year, the state began using a software system that flags 'ineligible' pension beneficiaries by matching databases on land, vehicles and income tax. Thousands of pensions have been stopped. A civil society group has filed an RTI application asking for the system's rules, error rates and a list of people dropped, saying many were wrongly cut off, including elderly people whose names were misspelt. The private vendor says its matching logic is a trade secret. The list of dropped beneficiaries contains personal details such as addresses, landholdings and health status. Your Minister says releasing anything may 'confuse' people. Complaints from beneficiaries are rising.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Dropped pensioners: Income, and a way to appeal.
- Civil society group: Accountability of the system.
- Vendor: Commercial secrets.
- Government: Saving leakage, public trust.
What pulls against what
Citizens deserve to know how a machine cut their pensions, but releasing the full list would expose personal data.
The options
- Refuse the RTI citing trade secrets and privacy: easy, but hides possible errors and harms trust.
- Release everything, including the list: maximum transparency, but exposes personal data.
- Release the rules and error rates, share anonymised data, tell each dropped person why and how to appeal, and order an independent audit: vendor and Minister may object.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Decisions about people's rights must be explainable; privacy protects individuals, not the system's mistakes.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Natural justice: audi alteram partem, hear the other side before taking away a benefit.