Ethics case studies · Case studies
Loyalty against law
You were recently appointed a member of a state electricity regulatory commission after a long career at a private power company. A tariff petition from that company has come before the commission. Many of your former colleagues, including your closest friend, worked on the petition and have called you to 'explain the background'. The petition asks for a tariff increase that would affect lakhs of consumers. You still hold a small number of shares in the company from an employee scheme. The law requires members to avoid conflicts of interest but does not list every situation. The commission has only three members, and if you step aside, the remaining two may disagree and delay the decision.
Identify the ethical issues involved. What course of action would you take, and why?
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Consumers: A fair tariff.
- Former company: A fair hearing, not favours.
- Commission: Credibility and timely decisions.
- You: Friendships and integrity.
What pulls against what
Old loyalties and a financial stake against the law's demand for an impartial regulator.
The options
- Hear the case and take the calls: fast, but biased in appearance and possibly in fact.
- Hear the case but refuse the calls: better, but the shareholding still creates a conflict.
- Disclose the interest, recuse from this petition, refuse private contact, and sell the shares: decision may be slower.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. A regulator must be impartial and be seen to be; a short delay costs less than lost public trust.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Nemo judex in causa sua: no one should judge a case in which they have an interest.