Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Case studies

Speed against fairness

Updated 2026-11-03

You are the project director of a state programme to use face recognition to mark attendance and release monthly ration for people in remote areas. The Chief Minister wants it launched statewide on a date already announced, three weeks away. Pilot results show the system works well for most users, but fails much more often for elderly people, manual labourers and people with poor lighting at home. When it fails, the person must travel to the block office to verify. The vendor says the error rate will fall 'with more data' after launch. Field staff warn that some elderly people may stop getting rations. Opposition leaders call it a 'surveillance tool'; supporters say it will end fake beneficiaries.

What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.

You ????
4 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You Elderly and labourersGovernmentHonest beneficiariesVendor
  • Elderly and labourers: Uninterrupted rations.
  • Government: A timely, credible launch.
  • Honest beneficiaries: No leakage to fakes.
  • Vendor: Contract and reputation.

What pulls against what

A fast launch meets a political deadline and cuts leakage, but a known bias would fall on the most vulnerable.

The options

  1. Launch statewide on the date: meets the deadline, but excludes vulnerable people.
  2. Cancel the project: avoids harm now, but loses a useful tool and wastes the investment.
  3. Launch on the date in phases, with a mandatory non-biometric fallback (OTP or a local official's verification), no one denied rations for a failed scan, and published error rates: slower full rollout.

One reasoned choice

Option 3. Technology should widen access, not narrow it; a fallback keeps the deadline and protects the weakest.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Do no harm: a public system must not shift its errors onto those least able to bear them.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →