Ethics case studies · Case studies
Speed against fairness
You are the senior-most Indian diplomat in a city abroad where fighting has suddenly broken out. About 2,000 Indian nationals have registered for evacuation. The first chartered flight, leaving in six hours, has 180 seats, and the airport may close soon after. Hundreds of people are at the embassy gate; the first to arrive are mostly young professionals who live nearby. Registrations also include pregnant women, elderly people, students stuck in a hostel across the city and workers with expired visas whose passports are held by employers. Some callers, including a well-connected businessman, are asking for seats for their relatives. Your staff say a first-come system is the only way to move quickly and avoid chaos at the gate.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Most vulnerable: Getting out safely.
- People at the gate: A fair, clear process.
- Workers without passports: Emergency papers.
- Embassy staff: Order and their own safety.
What pulls against what
A simple, fast method would favour the nearby and the connected; a fair one needs sorting time you barely have.
The options
- First come, first served: quick and orderly, but leaves the vulnerable and distant behind.
- Accept recommendations from influential callers: eases pressure, but is unfair and corrodes trust.
- Announce clear priority rules (medical need, pregnant women, children, elderly), issue emergency certificates, plan pickups for stranded groups: slower start, some anger at the gate.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Publicly stated, need-based rules are both fair and fast enough; refuse all special requests, in writing if needed.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Gandhi's talisman: think of the weakest person in the queue before deciding.