Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Case studies

Transparency against privacy

Updated 2026-11-03

You are the labour attaché at an Indian embassy. A nurse from Kerala, working at a private clinic abroad, has come to the embassy shelter after months of unpaid wages and abuse by her employer. She has filed a complaint with local authorities through the embassy. A popular news channel in India has learnt of the case and wants her name, photos and details of the abuse, saying public attention will force the host government to act faster. Her family wants publicity, but she has told you she wants complete confidentiality because she fears her employer's contacts and social shame back home. Diplomatic channels with the host country are slow but working. Your ambassador asks for your view.

Who are the stakeholders and what is at stake for each? How would you resolve the dilemma?

You ?????
5 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You The nurseHer familyMedia and publicEmbassyOther Indian workers
  • The nurse: Safety, justice, privacy.
  • Her family: Quick results.
  • Media and public: Accountability abroad.
  • Embassy: Effective, discreet diplomacy.
  • Other Indian workers: Systemic protection.

What pulls against what

Publicity might speed results, but it is her story and her safety; her consent must decide.

The options

  1. Share details with the media: may speed action, but violates her wishes and may endanger her.
  2. Refuse all comment: protects her, but loses public pressure on systemic abuse.
  3. Keep her identity confidential, brief the media on the issue in general terms, and push the case and broader worker protections through diplomatic channels: slower.

One reasoned choice

Option 3. Her informed consent decides on her identity; transparency about the pattern can still help others.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Dignity: a person is never just a means to a good outcome, however worthy.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →