Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Face scans at ration shops
You head the food and civil supplies department in a state. A vendor offers a face-recognition system for ration shops that it says will stop leakage by fake cardholders. A pilot showed less leakage, but also that some elderly and manual workers were wrongly rejected and went home without grain. There is no clear rule yet on how long the face data will be stored or who can access it.
Do you roll out the system across the state?
Three ways to act
- 1Roll it out now to stop leakage
- 2Roll it out only with a manual fallback and clear data rules
- 3Hold the rollout until an independent review
1. Roll it out now to stop leakage
Leakage may fall and savings may be large, but genuine beneficiaries may be denied food and privacy risks remain unsettled.
Values: Efficiency and preventing misuse of public funds
2. Roll it out only with a manual fallback and clear data rules
Rejected beneficiaries still get grain and data use is limited, but the rollout is slower and some leakage continues meanwhile.
Values: Balancing efficiency with rights and safeguards
3. Hold the rollout until an independent review
No one is wrongly denied by the new system, but leakage continues and the vendor and some officials may push back.
Values: Caution and the right to food over speed
Think about it
When technology makes a system more efficient but less forgiving, who should carry the cost of its errors?