Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Consent forms in a medicine trial
You are a district health officer. A private firm, with the required approvals, is running a trial of a new medicine for anaemia in some villages. During a visit you find that many participants signed consent forms in English they could not read, and some believe the medicine is a free government supply. The trial could help many women if it works, and stopping it would delay results by a year.
What do you do about the trial?
Three ways to act
- 1Report to the ethics committee and regulator and ask for a pause
- 2Let it run while the firm re-explains and re-takes consent
- 3Leave it, as the trial has approvals
1. Report to the ethics committee and regulator and ask for a pause
Participants' rights are protected and consent can be taken again properly, but the trial is delayed and the firm may resist.
Values: Autonomy and informed consent over speed
2. Let it run while the firm re-explains and re-takes consent
The trial continues and consent improves, but those already enrolled took part without truly understanding it.
Values: Correction without disruption
3. Leave it, as the trial has approvals
There is no conflict with the firm and the results come sooner, but people continue in a study they did not knowingly join.
Values: Formal compliance over substantive ethics
Think about it
Is a signature the same as consent? What makes consent real?