Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Clearing ghost names from a pension list
You are a district social welfare officer. A data match suggests that about one in ten names on the old-age pension list may be duplicates or people who have moved away. Your senior wants all flagged names stopped this month to show savings. Your field staff warn that the match is rough, and some genuine pensioners with spelling differences in their records may be cut off.
What do you do about the flagged names?
Three ways to act
- 1Stop all flagged pensions now
- 2Verify each flagged name in the field before stopping it
- 3Send notices and stop payment only if there is no reply in a set time
1. Stop all flagged pensions now
Savings are quick and fraud is cut, but some genuine elderly people may lose their only income without warning.
Values: Efficiency and protection of public money
2. Verify each flagged name in the field before stopping it
Genuine pensioners are protected, but it takes months and your senior may say you are slow.
Values: Due process and care for the vulnerable
3. Send notices and stop payment only if there is no reply in a set time
Most cases are sorted with less effort, but those who cannot read or travel may still miss the notice.
Values: Balance between speed and fairness
Think about it
When cleaning up a list, which error is worse: paying someone who should not be paid, or not paying someone who should?