Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Dilemmas

An RTI request your senior wants delayed

Updated 2026-11-14

You are the public information officer in a state department. An RTI application asks for file notings on why a large purchase was made from a single supplier without tender. The notings show that rules were bent under pressure, though no money seems to have changed hands. Your senior asks you to reply that the file is 'under examination' and let the 30-day limit pass.

How do you reply to the application?

Three ways to act

You
  1. 1Give the information within the time limit
  2. 2Give it, but first tell your senior in writing
  3. 3Follow your senior and delay the reply

1. Give the information within the time limit

The law is followed and the public learns how the decision was made, but your senior may be displeased and the department embarrassed.

Values: Transparency and the rule of law

2. Give it, but first tell your senior in writing

You follow the law and keep your senior informed, but you may face pressure in the days before the reply goes out.

Values: Lawfulness with respect for hierarchy

3. Follow your senior and delay the reply

You avoid friction at work, but you break the Act, and you may personally face a penalty from the information commission.

Values: Obedience over legal duty

Think about it

If a rule-bending decision caused no loss, does the public still have a right to know about it?

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →