Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
Advance knowledge of a new highway
You work in a state planning department and have seen the draft route of a new highway, not yet public. Land near the planned interchanges will rise sharply in value. Your elder brother, a farmer, mentions that he is thinking of selling his plot in that area to clear a debt. He has not asked you anything about the highway.
What do you say to your brother?
Three ways to act
- 1Say nothing about the highway
- 2Advise him in general to wait and get a fair valuation
- 3Tell him about the route so he can decide
1. Say nothing about the highway
Confidential information stays protected and you gain nothing from your post, but your brother may sell cheaply and later feel you let him down.
Values: Confidentiality and integrity over family interest
2. Advise him in general to wait and get a fair valuation
You may help him without naming the plan, but you are still using what you know, even if indirectly.
Values: Family care with a blurred line
3. Tell him about the route so he can decide
Your brother benefits, but you misuse official information, which may be a breach of rules and of public trust.
Values: Family loyalty over public duty
Think about it
Is it misuse of office if you gain nothing yourself but someone close to you does?