Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Dilemmas

A viral video and a constable

Updated 2026-10-20

You are the superintendent of police of a district. A video goes viral showing a constable slapping a young man at a traffic checkpoint. The clip is short. Your preliminary enquiry suggests the young man had abused and pushed the constable first, which the clip does not show. Public anger is high, a protest is planned for tomorrow, and the police association warns that suspending the constable will hurt morale.

What would you do, and what values does each choice serve?

Three ways to act

You
  1. 1Suspend the constable now, pending a full enquiry.
  2. 2Release full footage; order a time-bound enquiry, no suspension.
  3. 3Move the constable to non-public duty and meet protest leaders.

1. Suspend the constable now, pending a full enquiry.

Public anger may cool and the message on use of force is clear. The force may feel its side was ignored.

Values: Accountability and public trust over force morale

2. Release full footage; order a time-bound enquiry, no suspension.

The fuller picture reaches the public. Some may see it as defending the police, and the protest may grow.

Values: Transparency and fairness to the accused

3. Move the constable to non-public duty and meet protest leaders.

Tension is reduced without a finding of guilt. Both sides may see it as a half-measure.

Values: Prudence and dialogue; risks looking evasive

Think about it

How do you stay fair to an individual when public pressure demands a quick and visible response?

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →