Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A trial for the state team
You are on the selection panel for a state junior athletics team. A senior official's son finished just outside the selection mark in the trials. The official calls to say the boy was unwell that day and asks for him to be picked or given a re-trial. Another athlete from a poor family, who made the mark, would be dropped if the boy is added. No re-trial was offered to anyone else.
How do you respond to the request?
Three ways to act
- 1Stick to the trial results
- 2Offer a re-trial open to all who claim illness, with proof
- 3Add the boy to the team
1. Stick to the trial results
Selection stays merit-based and fair to the athlete who qualified, but the official may be displeased and you may face pressure.
Values: Merit and equal treatment
2. Offer a re-trial open to all who claim illness, with proof
The boy gets a fair chance under a clear rule, but the process is reopened and others may doubt why.
Values: Procedural fairness through a general rule
3. Add the boy to the team
The official is satisfied, but a qualified athlete loses a place and trust in the selection process falls.
Values: Deference to authority over merit
Think about it
If a rule is changed for one person, can it still be called a rule?