Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A transfer request out of turn
You manage transfers of teachers in a district. A teacher posted in a remote school asks to move to the district town because her father needs regular treatment there. Under the policy she must serve two more years in the remote post. Three other teachers have waited longer and have their own family reasons. If she moves, the remote school will have only one teacher until a new posting.
How do you decide on her request?
Three ways to act
- 1Follow the policy and keep her in place
- 2Grant a temporary attachment with a timeline
- 3Transfer her permanently on compassionate grounds
1. Follow the policy and keep her in place
The rules stay fair to those who waited, but she struggles to care for her father and may lose motivation.
Values: Fairness and consistency of rules
2. Grant a temporary attachment with a timeline
She can care for her father and the policy is not set aside for good, but others may see it as an exception and the remote school is short-staffed.
Values: Compassion within a structured exception
3. Transfer her permanently on compassionate grounds
Her need is fully met, but the waiting teachers feel cheated and the remote school's children lose a teacher.
Values: Compassion over rules and equity
Think about it
When compassion for one person means unfairness to others, how should a public servant weigh the two?