Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A senior's request on a tender
You head the procurement cell of a state department. A tender for hospital equipment is being evaluated. Your immediate senior, who writes your annual appraisal and has always supported you, asks you informally to 'look kindly' at one bidder, whose bid is slightly costlier but technically sound. Nothing is in writing. The lowest bidder meets all conditions but has a mixed record of delays in other states.
What would you do, and what values does each choice serve?
Three ways to act
- 1Evaluate strictly by tender criteria; ignore the informal request.
- 2Ask your senior to put any concerns in writing.
- 3Record the request and refer the evaluation to a committee.
1. Evaluate strictly by tender criteria; ignore the informal request.
The process stays clean and defensible. Your relationship with your senior may suffer, with possible effects on your appraisal.
Values: Integrity and objectivity over personal loyalty
2. Ask your senior to put any concerns in writing.
Concerns about delays, if genuine, enter the official record. The senior may withdraw the request or feel challenged.
Values: Transparency and accountability; tests the request's legitimacy
3. Record the request and refer the evaluation to a committee.
Your own discretion is removed and the decision is shared. It may delay procurement, and the senior may see it as distrust.
Values: Impartiality and self-protection; costs time
Think about it
Is loyalty to a senior ever compatible with duty to the public, and where exactly does it end?