Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A plastic ban and small vendors
You head the enforcement drive on single-use plastic in a city. Your teams have mostly fined street vendors and small shops, who say they cannot afford alternatives. Large packaged-goods firms, whose wrappers make up much of the waste, are covered by separate producer rules that your teams do not enforce. A vendors' union calls the drive unfair, while residents want cleaner streets.
How do you take the drive forward?
Three ways to act
- 1Continue fining all violators equally
- 2Pause fines on small vendors and help them find alternatives
- 3Push the producer-rule authority to act on large firms first
1. Continue fining all violators equally
The rule is applied as written and streets may get cleaner, but the burden falls hardest on the poorest sellers.
Values: Rule of law and environmental protection
2. Pause fines on small vendors and help them find alternatives
Vendors get time and support, but some plastic use continues and residents may see the drive as weak.
Values: Equity and a just transition
3. Push the producer-rule authority to act on large firms first
The main source is targeted and fairness improves, but this is outside your direct power and may take long.
Values: Fairness through addressing root causes
Think about it
Is it fair to enforce a good rule mainly where it is easiest to enforce?