Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Dilemmas

A junior officer's posts online

Updated 2026-11-14

You are a district superintendent of a government department. A capable junior officer in your team has been posting sharp comments on social media about a political party's policies, under his own name. The posts are not abusive and many people agree with them. A local party worker has complained to you that the officer is not neutral and asked for action.

How do you respond to the complaint?

Three ways to act

You
  1. 1Issue a formal warning under the conduct rules
  2. 2Counsel him privately to stop and remove the posts
  3. 3Take no action, as the posts are polite

1. Issue a formal warning under the conduct rules

Neutrality of the service is upheld, but the officer may feel his free speech is curbed and morale in the team may dip.

Values: Political neutrality and rule of law

2. Counsel him privately to stop and remove the posts

The issue may end quietly and his career is protected, but the complainant may see no action and the rule is applied informally.

Values: Guidance and proportion over formal action

3. Take no action, as the posts are polite

His expression is respected, but the public may doubt that he treats all citizens alike, whatever their politics.

Values: Freedom of expression over service neutrality

Think about it

Can a civil servant be neutral in public and still hold strong views in private? Where is the line?

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →