Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A friend's overtime claims
You are a section officer. While checking records, you notice that a colleague who is also a close friend has claimed overtime for evenings when the office register shows he left early. The amount is small. You know he has heavy loan repayments after his house was damaged by termites and repairs ran over budget. If you report it, a formal inquiry will follow and could affect his promotion.
What do you do about the claims?
Three ways to act
- 1Report the mismatch through the proper channel
- 2Speak to him privately and ask him to withdraw the claims
- 3Ignore it as too small to matter
1. Report the mismatch through the proper channel
The record is corrected and rules are applied evenly, but your friendship may end and he may face a penalty.
Values: Accountability and fairness to all over personal loyalty
2. Speak to him privately and ask him to withdraw the claims
He gets a chance to correct it without an inquiry, but the earlier false claims stay hidden from the system.
Values: Compassion and correction without punishment
3. Ignore it as too small to matter
There is no conflict now, but you have knowingly let a false claim pass, which may encourage it again.
Values: Loyalty and peace over duty
Think about it
Does a person's hardship change what honesty requires of you, or only how you act on it?