Ethics case studies · Dilemmas
A festival hamper from a contractor
You are an executive engineer in a public works division. During a festival, a contractor whose road project you supervise sends a large hamper of sweets, dry fruits and an expensive watch to your home. Your family has already opened it. Colleagues say such gifts are common at festival time and refusing them is seen as rude. The contractor's next bill is due for your approval next week.
What do you do with the gift?
Three ways to act
- 1Return the whole hamper with a polite note
- 2Keep the sweets, return the watch
- 3Keep it, but deposit the watch with the office and record it
1. Return the whole hamper with a polite note
Your position is clear and the bill can be judged on merit, but the contractor and some colleagues may see you as unfriendly.
Values: Integrity and objectivity over social custom
2. Keep the sweets, return the watch
You avoid seeming rude while refusing the costly item, but you have still accepted something from a party whose work you judge.
Values: Courtesy balanced against a partial line
3. Keep it, but deposit the watch with the office and record it
The gift is on record under the conduct rules, but the contractor may still expect goodwill in return.
Values: Rule-based compliance and disclosure
Think about it
Where does a courtesy end and an obligation begin, and who decides that?