Ethics case studies · Case studies
Transparency against privacy
You are the District Health Officer. Twelve students in a residential college hostel have tested positive for an infectious disease that spreads through close contact. It is treatable, but it carries social stigma in the area. A local news channel has obtained a partial list of names and wants to broadcast it, saying parents of other students have a right to know. The college principal wants the hostel closed and the affected students sent home, which could spread the infection to their villages. Some parents are demanding the names so they can keep their children away. The affected students have asked you, through a teacher, to keep their identities private because they fear losing their places and marriage prospects for their sisters.
Who are the stakeholders and what is at stake for each? How would you resolve the dilemma?
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Affected students: Treatment, dignity and privacy.
- Other students and parents: Safety and honest information.
- College: Running safely, reputation.
- Media: Public interest story.
- Villages: No spread of infection.
What pulls against what
The public needs enough truth to stay safe, but naming patients adds stigma without adding safety.
The options
- Release names: satisfies demands, but violates privacy and drives future cases into hiding.
- Say nothing: protects privacy, but rumours and panic spread.
- Share facts without names: case count, risk, testing and isolation inside campus; ask media not to name patients: some will call it secrecy.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Transparency means honest information about risk; identity is not needed for safety, so privacy and dignity win.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Right to privacy: recognised as part of Article 21 in the Puttaswamy judgment (2017).