Ethics case studies · Case studies
Transparency against privacy
As Municipal Commissioner, you face a large shortfall in property tax. A councillor proposes publishing the names, addresses and amounts of all defaulters on the corporation's website and on banners in each ward to 'shame' them into paying. The list includes big commercial owners who have not paid for years, but also thousands of small households, many with elderly or unemployed members, who owe small amounts. A local newspaper supports the idea, saying citizens have a right to know who is not paying. A residents' group warns that the list could expose vulnerable people to harassment by recovery agents. The state law allows publication of 'defaulters' lists' but does not specify the threshold.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Small households: Dignity and safety.
- Big defaulters: Avoiding exposure.
- Taxpaying citizens: Fairness and city services.
- Corporation: Revenue and public trust.
What pulls against what
Publishing lists can push payment and show fairness, but exposing every small debtor harms privacy without much gain.
The options
- Publish everyone: maximum pressure, but humiliates the vulnerable and invites harassment.
- Publish nothing: protects privacy, but protects big defaulters too.
- Publish large defaulters above a set threshold after notice; offer small households instalments and hardship waivers: lower immediate collection.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Transparency should be proportionate: the public interest is strongest for large, long-term defaulters.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Proportionality: a limit on a right must be no more than the purpose needs, as in Puttaswamy (2017).