Aspiran

Ethics case studies · Case studies

Speed against fairness

Updated 2026-11-03

Floods have hit eight blocks of your district, and you are the District Collector in charge of relief. The state has released cash assistance for each affected family. Village heads and local party workers have offered to hand out the cash within two days using their own lists. Your officials say a proper door-to-door survey with photos and bank-account checks will take three weeks. Families are living in camps and on embankments with nothing; shops have reopened and people need money for food and medicine. Last year, in a neighbouring district, quick distribution through local leaders led to many genuine victims being left out and others getting money twice. Reporters are asking why relief has not reached people yet.

What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.

You ????
4 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You Flood-hit familiesLeft-out poorLocal leadersAdministration
  • Flood-hit families: Quick, fair help.
  • Left-out poor: Not being missed by biased lists.
  • Local leaders: Role and influence.
  • Administration: Speed with accountability.

What pulls against what

Fast relief through informal lists against fair, verified relief that comes too late for urgent needs.

The options

  1. Use leaders' lists: fast, but risks exclusion, duplication and political capture.
  2. Wait for the full survey: accurate, but people go hungry for weeks.
  3. Two stages: a small immediate payment in camps through officials using existing ration and voter lists, then the balance after verification: more work, some errors early.

One reasoned choice

Option 3. Relief delayed is relief denied, but fairness can be built in stages; display lists publicly so people can flag gaps.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Rawls: judge the plan by how it treats the worst-off, here those missing from any list.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →