Ethics case studies · Case studies
Loyalty against law
You head procurement at a public sector power company. Your General Manager, who mentored you and recommended your promotion, asks you to add two technical conditions to a large transformer tender. The conditions are not needed for performance, but only one firm in the country can meet them. He says this firm 'always delivers on time', unlike past suppliers that caused costly delays, and that you both know how badly the project needs to finish before the summer. You have no evidence of any bribe. The rules require open competition and specifications based only on need. Two other firms have already asked about the tender. Refusing may damage your relationship with the GM, who writes your appraisal.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Company: Value for money and timely delivery.
- Other bidders: Fair chance to compete.
- General Manager: Project success, his judgement trusted.
- You: Loyalty to a mentor against the rules.
What pulls against what
A real concern about delays is being met by rigging the tender, and a mentor's trust is pulling you along.
The options
- Add the conditions: pleases the GM, but violates procurement rules and invites vigilance action.
- Refuse bluntly and report the GM: lawful, but may treat a concern as corruption without evidence.
- Decline in writing, and meet the concern lawfully: penalty clauses for delay, past-performance criteria open to all: tension with the GM.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Loyalty is owed to the mentor's goal, timely delivery, not to his method; the law offers fair tools for that goal.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Probity in procurement: decisions that can be explained openly to every bidder.