Ethics case studies · Case studies
Local pressure against the public interest
You are the Divisional Forest Officer of a hill division. Villages on the far side of a wildlife sanctuary have no all-weather road; in the monsoon, patients are carried on cots for hours. A proposal to build a road straight through a corridor used by tigers and elephants has strong local support. Elections are three months away, and leaders of all major parties back the road. Wildlife experts say the corridor links two reserves and a road would increase animal deaths and conflict. An alternative route around the corridor exists but is 14 kilometres longer and costlier. Villagers have gheraoed your office and say officials care more about animals than people.
Who are the stakeholders and what is at stake for each? How would you resolve the dilemma?
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Villagers: Access to health, markets, schools.
- Wildlife: An intact corridor.
- Political leaders: Voter support.
- Future generations: Lasting forests and safety.
What pulls against what
Strong, real local need, backed by all parties, against a long-term ecological public interest.
The options
- Approve the corridor road: quick relief and popular, but harms wildlife and future safety.
- Reject the road outright: protects the corridor, but leaves villagers stranded and angry.
- Back the longer route with central and state funds, plus an interim ambulance boat or bike service and mobile clinics: costlier, slower.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Both needs are real; the public interest is met by a route that serves people without breaking the corridor.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Intergenerational equity: today's choices should not shrink what the next generation inherits.