Ethics case studies · Case studies
Local pressure against the public interest
You are the Joint Commissioner of GST for a commercial city. Your team's checks on goods vehicles have caught many traders moving goods without valid e-way bills, and collections have risen. Two weeks before the main festival season, the city's traders' association calls a shutdown, saying the checks are 'harassment'. A delegation, joined by local politicians from different parties, asks you to stop roadside checks until the festival is over. Some genuine traders say officers delay trucks for hours over minor errors. Big tax evaders, however, are known to move most goods during festival rush. Your Commissioner says 'use your judgement but avoid a law-and-order problem'.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Honest traders: Business without harassment.
- Public exchequer: Tax lawfully due.
- Traders' association and politicians: Members' interests, support.
- Your officers: Clear, lawful mandate.
What pulls against what
Organised local pressure, mixed with some fair complaints, against enforcement that protects honest taxpayers.
The options
- Suspend checks: ends the shutdown, but signals that pressure works and helps evaders.
- Continue as before: firm, but ignores real harassment complaints and risks unrest.
- Keep checks but make them data-led and time-bound, set a fast grievance desk, and penalise officer misconduct: some anger remains.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Answer the fair part of the complaint, not the pressure; the law applies equally in festival season.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Kautilya: the ruler should collect revenue as a bee takes honey, without harming the flower.