Aspiran

Ethics case studies · District administration

Honesty against career safety

Updated 2026-11-03

You have just taken charge as District Collector of Kesarganj. Official records show every village in the district has a working household toilet, and your predecessor was praised for it. In your first field visits, you find that in about a third of the villages you check, toilets are incomplete, used as storerooms, or missing. Block officers privately say the figures were pushed up to meet a deadline. Your predecessor, now a senior officer in the state secretariat, will chair your performance review. A state-level review meeting is next week, and the Chief Secretary has asked every district to confirm its status. If you report the true picture, the district will lose its award and you may be seen as disloyal to a senior colleague. If you confirm the old figures, families who were counted as covered will get no further help.

What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.

You ?????
5 parties have something at stake here. Name them all before you open the answer.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer

Who has a stake

You Uncovered familiesYouPredecessorBlock officersState government
  • Uncovered families: Need toilets the records say they already have.
  • You: Integrity and career, both on the line.
  • Predecessor: Reputation and possible inquiry.
  • Block officers: Fear of blame for following orders.
  • State government: Credible data for policy.

What pulls against what

Telling the truth helps the uncovered families but may harm your career and a senior's name.

The options

  1. Confirm the old figures: safe for now, but families stay excluded and the falsehood grows.
  2. Report quietly to the predecessor only: protects a colleague, but delays correction and keeps you complicit.
  3. Report the verified picture with a recovery plan, without naming blame: costs the award, may strain relations.

One reasoned choice

Option 3, after a quick sample re-survey: public data must be true, and the focus is fixing gaps, not punishing people.

Values and terms to use in your answer

  • Integrity: acting on the same values in public and in private, even when it costs you.

More ethics case studies

All ethics case studies →