Ethics case studies · Case studies
Honesty against career safety
You are the newly appointed Director (Operations) of a public sector oil refinery. Going through maintenance files, you find that a mandatory pressure test on an ageing pipeline was signed off as done six months ago, but the test equipment log shows it was never used. Re-testing needs a ten-day shutdown during peak demand, costing the company heavily and missing a quarterly target that the board and ministry are watching closely. The plant head, who signed the file, is two months from retirement and well respected. He tells you the pipeline 'has run for years without trouble' and that raising this now will only bring an inquiry and bad press. Workers live in a township just beyond the pipeline.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Workers and township: Safety of life.
- Company and ministry: Output, targets, reputation.
- Plant head: Reputation at retirement.
- You: Duty of safety, career in a new post.
What pulls against what
A known safety gap against targets, a colleague's name and your own standing.
The options
- Keep running and test after the peak: meets targets, but gambles with lives.
- Do a quick partial check without telling the board: some comfort, but neither safe nor honest.
- Order the full test with a planned shutdown, inform the board in writing, and refer the false entry for inquiry: lost output, hard conversations.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Safety of life is not tradable for targets; telling the board early lets it manage the cost openly.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Accountability: the duty to answer for decisions, including uncomfortable ones, to those you serve.