Ethics case studies · Case studies
Honesty against career safety
You are a Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax. While reviewing old files for a training session, you notice that a large company's assessment, completed two years ago by your current senior, allowed a deduction that the law clearly did not permit. The error reduced the tax demand by a very large amount. The case can still be reopened, but the time limit runs out in five weeks. Your senior is known as fair and helped you during a family crisis. He is being considered for a top posting. If you raise it, he may face questions about whether the error was a mistake or something worse, and your working relationship will suffer. Colleagues hint that 'old cases are best left alone'.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Public exchequer: Revenue lawfully due.
- Senior officer: Reputation and fair hearing.
- Company: Certainty and correct assessment.
- You: Duty, gratitude, career.
What pulls against what
Correcting a costly error helps the public purse but may harm a respected senior and your own standing.
The options
- Let it lapse: easy, but loses revenue and breaks your duty.
- Raise it informally with the senior only: respectful, but if he refuses, time runs out.
- Tell the senior first, then put a factual note on file proposing reopening within the time limit, without alleging motive: strained ties.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Courtesy to the senior and duty to the law can both be met; the note states facts, and motive is for the system to judge.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Gandhi's talisman: recall the poorest person, who loses most when public revenue is lost.