Ethics case studies · Case studies
Compassion against rules
As Range Forest Officer, you find an elderly widow from a nearby village collecting dry firewood inside the core zone of a tiger reserve, where entry is banned. Your guards have caught her twice before; the rules require a fine and a case. She lives alone, has no gas connection, and says she cannot afford fuel. Villagers watching say that if she is let off, everyone will start entering. Your guards are worried: a tiger was seen in the area last week, and a woodcutter was attacked in another range last year. Your senior has asked for strict action to show results in an upcoming review of illegal entry.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Elderly widow: Fuel, survival and safety.
- Tiger reserve: An undisturbed core.
- Other villagers: Fair, consistent rules.
- Forest staff: Enforcement and safety.
What pulls against what
A poor woman's survival need against a rule that protects both tigers and people's lives.
The options
- Fine her and file a case: by the book, but punishes poverty and won't stop the need.
- Let her off quietly: kind, but unfair to others and risky for her.
- Warn on record, link her to a gas connection and pension, and work with the eco-development committee on fuelwood from buffer plantations: takes effort.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Rules work best when people have a lawful alternative; solving the fuel need protects her, the tiger and the rule.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Empathy: seeing the situation from her side before deciding what the rule requires.