Ethics case studies · Case studies
Compassion against rules
You are the Medical Superintendent of a district hospital. At midnight, a daily-wage worker arrives with his wife, who is in severe respiratory distress after childbirth at home. She needs intensive care. The hospital's free treatment scheme requires an identity document and an entry in the beneficiary list; the family has neither, as they moved from another state two months ago. The only free ICU bed is reserved under the scheme, and the accounts officer reminds you that last year the hospital was audited for 'irregular admissions' and two staff were penalised. A private hospital nearby would charge more than the family can pay. The duty doctor says the woman may not survive a transfer.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Patient and family: Her life.
- Duty doctor and staff: Duty of care, fear of audit.
- Accounts officer: Rules and financial propriety.
- Scheme beneficiaries: Fair access to reserved beds.
What pulls against what
A life in immediate danger against documentation rules meant to prevent misuse.
The options
- Refuse admission under the scheme: rule-safe, but may cost a life.
- Refer to the private hospital: shifts responsibility, but risks death in transit and debt.
- Admit now as an emergency, record reasons in writing, and complete papers later with the family's help: audit risk to you.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Rules exist to serve patients; in an emergency, the right to life comes first, and written reasons keep it transparent.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Article 21: courts have read emergency medical care into the right to life.