Ethics case studies · Case studies
Compassion against rules
You are the principal of a government senior secondary school. Meena, a bright Class 12 student, has 61% attendance; the board rule requires 75% to sit the exam, with a principal's discretion for 'medical reasons' only. Her father died last year, and she works mornings at a tea stall to support her mother and two younger siblings. Her test scores are among the best in the school, and a teacher has been helping her with notes in the evenings. Two other students with low attendance, whose parents are better off, were barred last year, and their parents complained of favouritism. The deadline to submit the eligible list is tomorrow. A medical certificate could be arranged, but it would be false.
What are the options available to you? Evaluate each and state what you would do.
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Meena and her family: Her education and the family's future.
- Other students: Equal application of rules.
- You: Fairness, honesty and discretion.
- Board: Integrity of the rule.
What pulls against what
Compassion for a hard-working student against a rule that must apply to all, with a tempting false shortcut.
The options
- Arrange a false medical certificate: helps Meena, but is dishonest and unfair to past students.
- Bar her under the rule: consistent, but ignores real hardship and may end her education.
- Write to the board today seeking a hardship exemption with evidence, and link the family to welfare schemes: may still be refused.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. Compassion should work through honest channels; and propose that the board's rule add a 'hardship' ground for all.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Equity: treating people according to need, which fair rules should allow for openly.