Ethics case studies · Case studies
Compassion against rules
After a cyclone, you are the officer in charge of relief camps in a coastal sub-division. Rations, tarpaulins and cash are given only to families on the official list of residents of affected villages. About 300 migrant workers from other states, who worked at fish-processing units and lived in rented sheds, have also lost everything. They are not on any local list, and their employers have left. Camp officials have started turning them away to avoid audit objections. Some residents complain that 'outsiders' will take their share. One migrant worker's child has fallen ill. The state's rules let you give aid only to listed families, but the disaster management plan speaks of 'all affected persons'.
Identify the ethical issues involved. What course of action would you take, and why?
Try it yourself first, then open the worked answer
Who has a stake
- Migrant workers: Food, shelter and dignity.
- Listed residents: Their full share of relief.
- Camp officials: Audit safety.
- Sick child: Immediate care.
What pulls against what
Rules tie aid to a residents' list; compassion and the disaster plan point to everyone who suffered.
The options
- Follow the list strictly: audit-safe, but leaves people destitute.
- Give them aid quietly from residents' stock: humane, but unrecorded and unfair to residents.
- Register them as affected persons under the disaster plan, seek extra stock and funds in writing, treat the child now: delay in approval, local resentment.
One reasoned choice
Option 3. The disaster plan's wider wording gives a lawful route for compassion; extra stock means no one's share is cut.
Values and terms to use in your answer
- Vivekananda: service to the suffering as service to the divine, without asking where they come from.