Q32 2 marks
Consider the following statements
Statement I: At the 28th United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP28), India refrained from signing the ‘Declaration on Climate and Health’.
Statement II: The COP28 Declaration on Climate and Health is a binding declaration and if signed, it becomes mandatory to decarbonize health sector.
Statement III: If India’s health sector is decarbonized, the resilience of its health-care system may be compromised.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
UPSC's answer: (c) Only one of the Statements II and III is correct and that explains Statement I
India did not endorse the COP28 Declaration on Climate and Health in December 2023, so I is right. II is wrong: the declaration is a voluntary statement in which countries 'commit to pursuing common objectives'; it creates no legal duty. III is the concern reported from Government sources at the time: cutting health-sector emissions could hold back the growth of health care that India still needs. So only III is right, and it explains I.
- (a) A: II is wrong; the declaration is not binding.
- (b) B: II is wrong, so 'both correct' fails.
- (d) D: III is correct.
The trap: COP 'declarations' and 'pledges' are almost never binding; binding obligations come from agreements like the Paris Agreement.