Q33 2 marks
Consider the following statements
Statement I: Scientific studies suggest that a shift is taking place in the Earth’s rotation and axis.
Statement II: Solar flares and associated coronal mass ejections bombarded the Earth’s outermost atmosphere with tremendous amount of energy.
Statement III: As the Earth’s polar ice melts, the water tends to move towards the equator.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
UPSC's answer: (b) Both Statement II and Statement III are correct but only one of them explains Statement I
Studies published in 2024 found that melting polar ice and glaciers move water towards the equator. This shifts mass away from the axis, which slightly slows Earth's spin (lengthening the day by milliseconds) and moves the rotation axis. So III is true and explains I. II is also true, since strong solar storms in 2024 did pour energy into the upper atmosphere, but solar storms do not change Earth's rotation or axis.
- (a) A: II is true but solar storms do not shift Earth's rotation or axis.
- (c) C: II is also a true statement, so 'only one is correct' fails.
- (d) D: both II and III are correct.
The trap: Two news events of 2024 are put side by side; only mass redistribution (water moving) changes rotation.