Q31 2 marks
Consider the following statements
Statement I: Studies indicate that carbon dioxide emissions from cement industry account for more than 5% of global carbon emissions.
Statement II: Silica-bearing clay is mixed with limestone while manufacturing cement.
Statement III: Limestone is converted into lime during clinker production for cement manufacturing.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
UPSC's answer: (b) Both Statement II and Statement III are correct but only one of them explains Statement I
Cement causes roughly 7-8% of global CO2 emissions, so Statement I holds. Cement is made by heating limestone with silica-bearing clay, so II is true, but mixing clay releases no CO2 by itself. The big source is III: in the kiln, limestone (calcium carbonate) breaks into lime (calcium oxide) and CO2, which is over half of cement's emissions; the rest comes from burning fuel for the heat. So both are correct, but only III explains I.
- (a) A: II is true but does not explain the emissions; mixing clay releases no CO2.
- (c) C: both II and III are correct, not just one.
- (d) D: both II and III are correct.
The trap: A statement can be true and still not explain; ask 'does this step release CO2?'