Notes · CSAT
Syllogisms and statements: what follows and what does not
By the end, you will be able to test a conclusion against given statements with a diagram, tell a conclusion from an assumption, and judge whether an argument is strong or weak.
The one rule of logical reasoning
Logical reasoning questions test one skill: deciding what must be true if the given statements are true. Nothing else counts. Your own knowledge of the world is set aside. If a statement says that all stones are fruits, you accept it for that question.
This is harder than it sounds, because the mind fills gaps without asking. A statement that some students are tall does not say that some students are not tall. A statement that sales rose does not say why. Most wrong options are things that are probably true in life but are not forced by the statements.
So the test for every conclusion is the same. Ask: can I imagine a case where the statements are all true and this conclusion is false? If yes, the conclusion does not follow. If no such case can exist, it follows.
Three kinds of question use this test. Syllogisms give two or three statements about groups and ask which conclusions follow. Statement and conclusion questions give a sentence or a short passage. Statement and assumption questions ask what the speaker has taken for granted. This note takes them in turn.
Four kinds of statement and how to draw them
Every syllogism statement is one of four kinds.
All A are B. Draw the circle for A inside the circle for B. It does not say that all B are A.
No A is B. Draw two circles that do not touch. This one can be turned round: no B is A.
Some A are B. Draw two circles that overlap. In logic, some means at least one. It does not rule out all. This can also be turned round: some B are A.
Some A are not B. At least one A lies outside B. This cannot be turned round. It tells you nothing about whether some B are not A.
By the usual convention of these questions, the groups named are taken to have members. So from all A are B you may conclude that some A are B and that some B are A.
The method is to draw the statements and then try to break each conclusion. When a statement can be drawn in more than one way, draw every way that fits. Take some cats are dogs and all dogs are animals. The overlap of cats and dogs must sit inside animals, however you draw it. So some cats are animals follows. All animals are dogs fails, because the animal circle can be drawn larger than the dog circle.
Chains, broken links and the either-or case
Some patterns come up again and again.
All with all gives all. All pens are books and all books are tables gives all pens are tables.
All with no gives no. All roses are flowers and no flower is a tree gives no rose is a tree.
Some with all gives some, if the all statement starts from the shared group. Some cats are dogs and all dogs are animals gives some cats are animals.
Some with some gives nothing. Some doctors are singers and some singers are painters says nothing definite about doctors and painters. The singers who are doctors and the singers who are painters may be different people.
All followed by some also gives nothing about the first group. All teachers are readers and some readers are writers does not give some teachers are writers, because the readers who write may all be non-teachers.
The either-or case needs care. When two conclusions are some A are B and no A is B, exactly one of them must be true in any world. If neither follows by itself, the answer is either I or II follows, where that option is offered. The same holds for the pair all A are B and some A are not B.
Conditional statements follow a similar discipline. From if it rains, the match is cancelled, and the match was not cancelled, you can conclude that it did not rain. From the match was cancelled, you can conclude nothing about rain, because a match can be cancelled for other reasons.
Conclusions, assumptions and arguments
These three words mean different things, and the questions depend on the difference.
A conclusion comes after the statement. It is something that must be true if the statement is true. From the city has banned plastic bags from next month, it follows that shops there may not hand out plastic bags from next month. It does not follow that plastic harms the environment. That may be the reason for the ban, but the statement does not say so.
An assumption comes before the statement. It is something the speaker must have taken for granted for the statement to make sense. A notice that says please use the stairs, the lift is under repair, assumes that people are able to use the stairs. It does not assume that the lift will never work again. A handy test is to deny the assumption. If the statement then becomes pointless, the assumption is implicit.
An argument is a reason given for or against a proposal. A strong argument is directly related to the question and rests on a real consequence or a sound principle. A weak argument is vague, is only an opinion, appeals to habit or to what others do, or goes to an extreme. On whether schools should open later in winter, a reason about children's safety in fog is strong. The reason that schools have always opened at the same time is weak, because it only repeats the present practice.
Words such as only, all, always and never make a statement easy to break. A conclusion containing them needs equally strong wording in the statement.
A routine for the examination hall
Use the same steps each time.
One. Read the statements and mark the key words: all, some, no, only, if.
Two. For a syllogism, draw the circles. Draw the least that the statements force, not what seems natural.
Three. Take one conclusion at a time and try to draw a case that breaks it. If you can, strike it off.
Four. If two conclusions both fail, check whether they are a complementary pair before choosing neither.
Five. For statements in words, ask of each option: is this said, or am I adding it?
The common traps are few. Treating some as some but not all. Turning round an all statement. Reading a cause into a statement that gives only a fact. Accepting a conclusion because it is true in real life. Naming these traps to yourself as you practise makes them easier to see under time pressure.
Key facts
- A conclusion follows only if no case can make the statements true and the conclusion false.
- Some means at least one; it does not rule out all.
- All A are B cannot be turned round; No A is B and Some A are B can.
- Some with some gives no definite conclusion.
- Some A are B and No A is B form a complementary pair: either one or the other is true.
- If P then Q, and not Q, gives not P. Q alone gives nothing about P.
- A conclusion comes after the statement; an assumption comes before it.
- A strong argument is relevant and rests on a real consequence; habit and opinion are weak.
How the exam uses it
These questions take little time once the diagram habit is formed, and they carry no reading load, so they are good ones to attempt early. The marks are lost by adding outside knowledge. Decide each conclusion by trying to break it, and treat words like only, all and never in an option as a warning.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- What does some mean in a syllogism, and what does it not rule out?
- Which of the four kinds of statement can be turned round?
- Why do two some statements give no definite conclusion?
- When is the answer either I or II follows?
- How do you test whether an assumption is implicit in a statement?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of Preliminary Examination Paper II (logical reasoning and analytical ability); Standard rules of categorical logic as taught in school and undergraduate texts; the convention that named groups have members is the one these questions use
Syllabus topic: Logical reasoning and analytical ability (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Arrangements, blood relations, directions and codingCSAT
- Decision making: reading the situation and choosing a course of actionCSAT
- Inference, assumptions and toneCSAT
- Interpersonal skills: listening and respondingCSAT
- Numbers, percentages and ratios: methods that save timeCSAT
- Setting priorities and solving problems step by stepCSAT