Notes · CSAT
Arrangements, blood relations, directions and coding
By the end, you will have a way of putting each of four common puzzle types on paper: a seating table, a family tree, a direction sketch and a code key.
Put it on paper
The four kinds of question in this note look different, but they share one feature. Each gives information in sentences that is much easier to handle as a picture. The skill is to turn the words into a table, a tree, a sketch or a key, and then read the answer off it.
Trying to hold the clues in the head is the usual cause of error. A sketch takes fifteen seconds and removes the load on memory. It also shows at once when a clue has been misread, because the picture stops making sense.
Two general rules apply to all four types. First, start with the clue that is definite. A clue such as C sits in the middle fixes a position. A clue such as D is not at an end only rules something out, and is best used later. Second, when a clue allows two possibilities, draw both and carry them forward until another clue removes one. Guessing at this stage and hoping is slower in the end.
These questions often come in sets, with three or four questions on one arrangement. The first few minutes go into the picture. After that each question takes seconds. That makes a set a good investment, provided the picture is right, so check it against every clue once before answering.
Arrangements and ranking
For people in a row, draw numbered blanks. Note which way they face. If they face north, their left is your left as you look at the page. If they face south, left and right swap.
Take five friends in a row facing north. A is at the left end, C is in the middle, B is to the immediate right of C, and D is not at an end. Seats are 1 to 5. A takes seat 1 and C seat 3. B takes seat 4. D cannot take seat 5, so D takes seat 2, and E is left with seat 5.
For a round table, draw a circle with marked seats. If everyone faces the centre, a person's right is the anticlockwise side and left is the clockwise side. Fix one person anywhere to begin; in a circle only relative positions matter. Opposite means directly across, which exists only when the number of seats is even.
Ranking questions use one relation. If a person is 12th from the left in a row of 40, the position from the right is 40 - 12 + 1 = 29. The one is added because the person is counted from both sides. In reverse, the total is the sum of the two positions minus one.
For comparisons such as taller and shorter, write the names along a line with the greatest at one end. A is taller than B, C is shorter than B, and D is taller than A gives the order D, A, B, C.
Blood relations
Draw a family tree. Put each generation on its own level: grandparents on top, parents below, children below them. Join a married couple with a double line and brothers and sisters with a single line. Mark each person as male or female when the question says so, and leave it blank when it does not.
That last point decides many questions. A is B's brother tells you that A is male. It tells you nothing about B. If C is A's mother and D is C's father, then B is a grandchild of D. Whether B is a grandson or a granddaughter is not known.
For a statement made while pointing at someone, start from the speaker and move one step at a time. Arun says of a woman, her mother is the only daughter of my mother. The only daughter of Arun's mother is Arun's sister. The woman is the daughter of Arun's sister, so she is his niece.
Learn the few terms that link two families. A spouse's brother or sister, and a brother's or sister's spouse, are brother-in-law or sister-in-law. A son's wife is a daughter-in-law. A brother's or sister's child is a nephew or niece. A parent's brother or sister is an uncle or aunt, and their child is a cousin.
Where the question uses symbols, such as P + Q means P is the father of Q, write the meaning of each symbol on the page first, then translate the expression piece by piece into the tree.
Directions
Draw a small compass in the corner of the page with north at the top, east to the right, south at the bottom and west to the left. Then trace the journey as a line, one leg at a time.
Turns are made relative to the direction the person is facing, not relative to the page. A person facing south who turns left now faces east. It helps to turn the page, or to imagine standing on the line. A right turn is a quarter turn clockwise, a left turn is a quarter turn anticlockwise, and an about turn reverses the direction.
For the final distance from the start, add up movement along north and south separately from movement along east and west. If the two results are both non-zero, the straight-line distance is the hypotenuse. Three kilometres north and four kilometres east leave the person five kilometres from the start, since 3, 4, 5 is a right-angled triangle. Other useful sets are 6, 8, 10 and 5, 12, 13.
Shadow questions rest on one fact. The sun is in the east in the morning, so shadows fall towards the west. In the evening the sun is in the west and shadows fall towards the east. If a person's shadow in the morning falls to the right, then west is to the right, and the person is facing south.
Coding and decoding
A code question gives a word and its coded form, and asks you to code or decode another word by the same rule. The task is to find the rule.
Write the alphabet with position numbers once at the start of the paper: A is 1, M is 13, Z is 26. A quick anchor is E 5, J 10, O 15, T 20, Y 25.
Then test the common rules in turn. Is each letter shifted by a fixed number, as when CAT becomes DBU, each letter moving one place forward? Does the shift change by position, such as plus one, plus two, plus three? Is each letter replaced by its opposite in the alphabet, A with Z and B with Y? For opposites, the two position numbers always add up to 27. Is the word written backwards? Is the code a number made from positions, such as the sum of the letters?
Check the rule on every letter of the example before applying it. A rule that fits the first two letters and not the third is not the rule.
In substitution questions, one word is called by another name: if red is called blue and blue is called green. First answer the question in ordinary language. Then look up what that answer is called in the code. Do not go one step further than asked.
Key facts
- Start with the definite clue; carry two cases forward when a clue allows two.
- Facing the centre of a circle: right is anticlockwise, left is clockwise.
- Position from the other end = total - position + 1.
- A is B's brother fixes A's gender, not B's.
- Turns are relative to the direction faced, not to the page.
- Right-angle sets: 3, 4, 5; 6, 8, 10; 5, 12, 13.
- Morning shadows fall west; evening shadows fall east.
- Opposite letters add up to 27: A and Z, B and Y, M and N.
How the exam uses it
These are reliable marks for a candidate who draws. Take sets where one picture answers several questions, and check the picture against every clue before answering. Leave an arrangement that still has three or more open cases after two minutes; it can be finished later if time remains.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- In a circle where everyone faces the centre, which way is a person's right?
- Sunil is 15th from the top and 26th from the bottom of a list. How many names are on the list?
- P is Q's sister. What do you know about Q's gender?
- A person facing west turns right and then right again. Which way do they face?
- What is the opposite letter of K, and how do you find it quickly?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of Preliminary Examination Paper II (logical reasoning and analytical ability; general mental ability)
Syllabus topic: Logical reasoning and analytical ability (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Decision making: reading the situation and choosing a course of actionCSAT
- Inference, assumptions and toneCSAT
- Interpersonal skills: listening and respondingCSAT
- Numbers, percentages and ratios: methods that save timeCSAT
- Setting priorities and solving problems step by stepCSAT
- Puzzles and visual reasoning: sets, counting, cubes and mirrorsCSAT