Notes · CSAT
Puzzles and visual reasoning: sets, counting, cubes and mirrors
By the end, you will be able to turn a word puzzle into an equation or a diagram, count figures without missing any, and handle cube, dice, mirror and paper-folding questions by rule.
Word puzzles: name the unknown
A puzzle looks hard because the information is wrapped in a story. Unwrap it by giving a letter to what is not known and writing each sentence as a relation.
A father is three times as old as his son. Twelve years from now he will be twice as old. Call the son's age x. The father is 3x. In twelve years, 3x + 12 = 2 (x + 12). So x = 12. Check: 36 and 12 now, 48 and 24 later.
Some puzzles have two unknowns and two facts. A farm has hens and goats, 20 heads and 56 legs in all. A shortcut avoids algebra. Suppose all 20 were hens: that gives 40 legs. The extra 16 legs come from goats, at two extra legs for each goat. So there are 8 goats and 12 hens.
Weighing puzzles ask for the fewest weighings on a balance to find one odd coin. Each weighing has three outcomes: left heavier, right heavier, or equal. So divide the coins into three groups, not two. Among 8 coins with one heavier, weigh three against three. If they balance, the heavy coin is among the remaining two and one more weighing finds it. If not, take the heavier three and weigh one against one. Two weighings are enough.
In every puzzle, put the answer back into the story as a last step. A puzzle answer that fits every sentence is right.
Sets and Venn diagrams
When people or things belong to overlapping groups, draw two overlapping circles inside a box. The box is everyone. The overlap is those in both groups.
The key relation is this: the number in at least one group equals the first group plus the second group minus the overlap. The overlap is subtracted because it has been counted twice.
In a class of 50, 30 play cricket, 25 play football and 10 play both. Those who play at least one game number 30 + 25 - 10 = 45. So 5 play neither.
The same relation finds the overlap. Forty people each like tea or coffee or both. Twenty-eight like tea and 22 like coffee. Then 28 + 22 - both = 40, so 10 like both.
Fill the diagram from the inside outwards. Write the overlap first. Then the part of each circle outside the overlap: 20 play only cricket and 15 play only football. Then the part of the box outside both circles. Questions that ask for only one game, exactly one game or at least one game can then be read directly from the picture.
Watch the wording. Thirty play cricket includes those who also play football. Thirty play only cricket does not. Reading one for the other is the most common mistake in these questions.
Counting without missing any
Counting questions are lost by counting in no particular order. Count by size or by type, one class at a time.
For squares in a grid of 3 by 3 small squares, count by size. There are 9 squares of side one, 4 of side two and 1 of side three, making 14.
For a square with both diagonals drawn, count triangles by how many small pieces each uses. There are 4 small triangles. Two neighbouring small triangles join to make a larger one, and there are 4 such pairs. No triangle uses three pieces, and four pieces make the square itself. The total is 8.
For pairs chosen from a group, such as handshakes, each of n people shakes hands with n - 1 others, and each handshake is counted twice in that product. So the number is n (n - 1) / 2. Ten people give 10 x 9 / 2 = 45 handshakes. The same count gives the number of matches when every team plays every other team once, and the number of lines joining n points when no three lie on one line.
When the order matters, as with seats or ranks, do not divide by two. Ask each time: would swapping the two give a different outcome? If not, the pair has been counted twice.
Cubes and dice
A large cube is painted on all faces and then cut into small equal cubes, n along each edge. The small cubes fall into four classes by position.
Corner cubes have three painted faces. There are always 8.
Cubes along an edge but not at a corner have two painted faces. Each of the 12 edges has n - 2 of them, so there are 12 (n - 2).
Cubes in the middle of a face have one painted face. Each of the 6 faces has (n - 2) squared of them.
Cubes inside have no painted face. They form a smaller cube of side n - 2, so there are (n - 2) cubed.
For 27 small cubes, n is 3: 8 corners, 12 with two faces, 6 with one face and 1 with none. For 64 small cubes, n is 4: 8, 24, 24 and 8. The four numbers must add up to the total, which is a ready check.
On a standard die the numbers on opposite faces add up to 7, so 1 is opposite 6, 2 is opposite 5 and 3 is opposite 4. If the question does not call the die standard, use the views given. Two numbers that appear together in any view are on neighbouring faces and cannot be opposite each other. A number that is seen next to four different numbers must have the remaining number opposite it.
Mirrors, folds and symmetry
A mirror placed beside an object swaps left and right and leaves top and bottom alone. So the mirror image of a word has its letters in reverse order, and each letter is flipped left to right. Letters such as A, H, I, M, O, T, U, V, W, X and Y look the same when flipped this way. A word reads the same in the mirror only if it is made of such letters and is spelt the same backwards, as MOM is.
For a clock seen in a mirror, subtract the time shown from 12 hours. Write 12:00 as 11:60 to make the subtraction easy. A mirror showing 3:15 means the real time is 11:60 - 3:15 = 8:45.
A mirror placed below an object, or a reflection in water, swaps top and bottom and leaves left and right alone.
In paper-folding questions, each fold doubles the number of layers. A hole punched through all layers appears once in each layer. A sheet folded in half twice has four layers, so one punch gives four holes when the sheet is opened, as long as the hole is not on a fold line. Their positions are mirror images of one another across each fold line. To be sure, unfold one step at a time in your sketch and reflect the holes across the fold just opened.
Key facts
- At least one group = first + second - both.
- Pairs from n things: n (n - 1) / 2.
- Squares in a 3 by 3 grid: 9 + 4 + 1 = 14.
- Painted cube cut n to an edge: 8 corners; 12 (n - 2) with two faces; 6 (n - 2) squared with one; (n - 2) cubed with none.
- Standard die: opposite faces add up to 7.
- A balance has three outcomes, so split coins into three groups.
- Clock in a mirror: real time = 11:60 minus the time shown.
- Each fold doubles the layers; one punch gives one hole per layer.
How the exam uses it
Most of these questions have a formula or a fixed way of counting behind them, so they are quick for a prepared candidate and slow for anyone working from first principles in the hall. Learn the cube counts and the pair formula, draw the Venn diagram every time, and put each puzzle answer back into the story before marking it.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- In a group of 60, 35 read Hindi papers, 30 read English papers and 15 read both. How many read neither?
- Why are coins split into three groups in a weighing puzzle?
- A painted cube is cut into 125 small cubes. How many have no painted face?
- Six teams play each other once. How many matches are played?
- A clock in a mirror shows 7:20. What is the real time?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of Preliminary Examination Paper II (general mental ability; decision making and problem solving); NCERT Mathematics textbooks, Classes VI to VIII: chapters on visualising solid shapes and symmetry
Syllabus topic: General mental ability (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Arrangements, blood relations, directions and codingCSAT
- Decision making: reading the situation and choosing a course of actionCSAT
- Inference, assumptions and toneCSAT
- Interpersonal skills: listening and respondingCSAT
- Numbers, percentages and ratios: methods that save timeCSAT
- Setting priorities and solving problems step by stepCSAT