Notes · CSAT
Setting priorities and solving problems step by step
By the end, you will be able to rank competing demands by harm, reversibility and dependence, and work a problem from its statement to a checked solution.
Two kinds of question
The previous note dealt with choosing one course of action in a single situation. This note takes up two related tasks.
The first is setting priorities. Several things need doing, time or resources are short, and the question asks what you will do first or in what order. All the tasks may be worth doing. The skill is in the order.
The second is problem solving in the plain sense: a problem with conditions is stated, and you have to find an arrangement, an allocation or a plan that meets all the conditions. These questions are close to reasoning puzzles, but they are set in a working context, such as dividing staff among duties or fitting jobs into a schedule.
Both tasks reward method over speed. In a priority question, a candidate who ranks by a fixed set of tests will reach the same answer every time. In a problem with conditions, a candidate who writes the conditions down and tests the options against them will not be misled by an option that meets three conditions out of four.
Urgent and important are different things
A task is urgent when it has to be done soon or the chance is lost. A task is important when much depends on it. The two do not always go together. A ringing telephone is urgent and may not be important. A plan for next year's water supply is important and not urgent today.
Sorting tasks on these two questions gives four groups. What is both urgent and important is done first and by you. What is important but not urgent is given a fixed time, so that it is not pushed out for ever. What is urgent but not important is handed to someone else or dealt with briefly. What is neither is left.
The common error is to let the urgent crowd out the important. A day spent only on what is pressing leaves the larger work untouched, and neglected important work turns in time into a crisis.
In an examination question, look for words that show urgency, such as within the hour, before the office closes, or already waiting, and words that show importance, such as safety, legal deadline, or many people affected. Mark each task on both before ranking.
Tests for ranking
When several tasks are both urgent and important, rank them by these tests, roughly in this order.
Life and safety. A risk to life or of serious injury comes before everything else.
Reversibility. Harm that cannot be undone comes before harm that can. A missed legal deadline that ends a right is worse than a late report that can be sent tomorrow with an apology.
Number and vulnerability. Where the harm is of the same kind, what affects many comes before what affects few, and those least able to help themselves come first.
Dependence. A task on which other tasks or other people are waiting comes before a task that stands alone. Ten minutes spent giving a team its instructions lets ten people begin work.
Time to act. A step that takes two minutes and sets something in motion, such as a telephone call that sends an ambulance, is done before a long task of equal weight.
Rank and noise are not tests. A demand does not move up the list because the person making it is senior or loud. But a lawful instruction with a real deadline is a fact to be weighed like any other.
Setting priorities also means saying what will wait and telling those affected. An officer who quietly drops a task has not set a priority; the task has simply been lost.
Solving a problem with conditions
A stated problem is solved in six steps.
State the problem. Say in one sentence what is to be found: who does which duty, which job goes on which day, how much each unit gets.
List the conditions. Write each one separately, in short form. Include the ones that are easy to miss, such as each person does exactly one duty or no one works two days running.
Start with the tightest condition. A condition that fixes something outright, such as A must be on Monday, is used first. Then use conditions that leave only two possibilities.
Build or eliminate. Either build the arrangement step by step, or take each answer option and strike it out the moment it breaks a condition. With four options, elimination is often faster.
Check. Run the chosen answer against every condition, not only the ones you used to find it.
Read what is asked. A question may ask what must be true, what could be true, or what cannot be true. Must be true needs the statement to hold in every arrangement the conditions allow. Could be true needs only one.
For problems of allocation with numbers, add up first. If five units share forty hours and three of them need ten each, the other two share ten. Totals often settle the question before any detail is needed.
Habits that help
Write, do not hold in the head. Three tasks with two marks each, or four conditions in short form, take half a minute to write and save more than that.
In a priority question, find the item with a risk to safety or an irreversible loss before reading the options.
In a problem with conditions, do not stop at the first option that seems to fit. Check it against every condition.
The same habits serve in the Main Examination, where an answer on a crisis is expected to say what is done at once, what within days, and what over the longer term.
Key facts
- Urgent means soon or lost; important means much depends on it.
- Life and safety come first.
- Harm that cannot be undone ranks above harm that can.
- A task on which others are waiting ranks above one that stands alone.
- Rank and loudness of the person asking are not tests of priority.
- In a problem with conditions, start with the tightest condition and check the answer against all.
- Must be true holds in every allowed arrangement; could be true needs one.
How the exam uses it
Priority questions are decided by safety, reversibility and dependence, in that order, and by noticing which task can be handed to someone else. Problems with conditions are decided by writing the conditions down and eliminating options. Neither needs prior knowledge, so marks here depend on calm and method.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- Give one example of a task that is urgent but not important, and one that is important but not urgent.
- List the tests for ranking tasks that are all urgent and important.
- Why does a task on which others are waiting come early?
- What are the six steps for a problem with conditions?
- What is the difference between must be true and could be true?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of Preliminary Examination Paper II (decision making and problem solving); All fifteen questions were written for this note and are not taken from any examination
Syllabus topic: Decision making and problem solving (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Arrangements, blood relations, directions and codingCSAT
- Decision making: reading the situation and choosing a course of actionCSAT
- Inference, assumptions and toneCSAT
- Interpersonal skills: listening and respondingCSAT
- Numbers, percentages and ratios: methods that save timeCSAT
- Puzzles and visual reasoning: sets, counting, cubes and mirrorsCSAT